Home » Blog » Breastfeeding » Why use a Haakaa instead of a pump?

Why use a Haakaa instead of a pump?

The Haakaa vs. Traditional Pumps: A Closer Look
In the world of breastfeeding, the choice between using a Haakaa and a traditional breast pump can significantly impact a mother’s experience. While both tools serve the purpose of milk collection, they do so in fundamentally different ways, each with its own set of advantages.
Understanding the Haakaa
The Haakaa is a silicone breast pump designed primarily for catching milk during let-down. Unlike traditional pumps, which actively extract milk through mechanical means, the Haakaa relies on gentle suction to collect milk that would otherwise leak from the breast not being nursed on. This makes it particularly useful for mothers who want to maximize their milk collection without the hassle of a more complex pumping system.
One of the standout features of the Haakaa is its simplicity. It is a manual device that requires no batteries or electricity, making it an eco-friendly option. Mothers can easily attach it to the opposite breast while nursing, allowing them to collect milk that would typically be lost to breast pads or clothing. This not only helps in building a milk stash but also reduces waste and the need for disposable products.
Benefits of Using a Haakaa
1. Ease of Use: The Haakaa is incredibly user-friendly. Simply squeeze the pump to create suction and attach it to the breast. This straightforward mechanism allows mothers to multitask, whether they are nursing or engaging in other activities.
2. Gentle Milk Collection: The Haakaa’s design promotes a gentle let-down, which can be more comfortable for some mothers compared to the more aggressive suction of electric pumps. This can be particularly beneficial for those experiencing engorgement or discomfort.
3. Portability: Its lightweight and compact design make the Haakaa easy to carry around. Mothers can use it discreetly in various settings, whether at home or on the go, without the need for a power source.
4. Cost-Effective: Compared to electric pumps, the Haakaa is significantly more affordable. This makes it an attractive option for mothers who may not want to invest heavily in pumping equipment.
5. Versatility: While primarily used for catching let-down, the Haakaa can also be used in conjunction with electric pumps. This allows mothers to maximize their milk output by using both methods simultaneously.
When to Choose a Traditional Pump
While the Haakaa offers numerous benefits, there are scenarios where a traditional pump may be more suitable. For instance, mothers who need to pump large quantities of milk quickly or those who are exclusively pumping may find electric pumps more efficient. Traditional pumps often provide adjustable suction levels and faster milk extraction, which can be crucial for building a substantial milk supply.
Conclusion
In summary, the choice between a Haakaa and a traditional pump ultimately depends on individual needs and circumstances. The Haakaa shines in its simplicity, ease of use, and ability to collect milk without the complexities of a mechanical pump. For mothers looking for a gentle, effective way to catch let-down milk, the Haakaa is an excellent choice. However, for those requiring more robust pumping capabilities, a traditional pump may be the better option. Each tool has its place in the breastfeeding journey, and understanding their differences can help mothers make informed decisions that best suit their lifestyles.

Does a Haakaa count as a pumping session?

You can definately use the Haakaa as your primary pump. Some women use our pumps simply to catch excess milk that would otherwise be lost in a nursing pad. However, you can use it to express as you would with any manual pump.

What are the negatives of Haakaa?

The main downside of the Haakaa is the potential for oversupply (which makes you more likely to get blocked ducts and mastitis) and the risk of depriving your baby of the milk they need.

Can Haakaa replace a breast pump?

How Haakaa performs compared to an electric breast pump? Haakaa is by no means can replace an electric pump. But it is soo convenient to use (especially at home) because you don’t need to prepare so much stuff before pumping. Cleaning is also a breeze because it is a one-piece product.

Is Haakaa as good as pumping?

Haakaa is not a replacement to a real pump. Haakaa is essentially a glorified milk let down catcher. It’s not going to pull your milk out the way you need if someone needs to watch your baby and you need to have bottles of milk pumped for them.

Does Haakaa only get foremilk?

The pump helps you collect both foremilk and rich hindmilk.

Does using a Haakaa create oversupply?

A Haakaa is a type of manual breast pump that is often used to collect milk from the opposite breast/chest while breastfeeding or chestfeeding. While a Haakaa can be a useful tool for collecting extra milk or relieving engorgement, it can also contribute to an oversupply of milk if not used carefully.

Can I exclusively pump with Haakaa?

Can you pump using the Haakaa only? Yes, you absolutely can! I breastfeed my twin babies, and when it comes to pumping breast milk, I use my both of my Haakaa manual pumps more than I use my Medela pump. It is a great way to catch that precious breast milk.

What is the Haakaa controversy?

Many lactation consultants are concerned about the wide-spread use of silicone breast pumps, such as the Haakaa. They see issues like: oversupply. vasospasm/ pain (because it’s constant suction is left on too long) slow weight gain (because the Haakaa is taking the milk the baby needs)

Does Haakaa count as a pumping session?

You can definately use the Haakaa as your primary pump. Some women use our pumps simply to catch excess milk that would otherwise be lost in a nursing pad. However, you can use it to express as you would with any manual pump.

Why do I get more milk from Haakaa than pump?

By using the Haakaa at the same time you are breastfeeding, your body releases increased levels of Oxytocin and Prolactin hormones which increase milk supply and output.

Natasha Lunn

Tash is an IBCLC and Business Coach helping fellow IBCLCs create fun, profitable businesses that are more than just an expensive hobby. Before becoming an IBCLC and starting her private practice - The Boobala, Tash graduated as an Osteopath in 2008 and has been in Private Practice in South West Sydney. She was also a volunteer Breastfeeding Counsellor and Community Educator with the Australian Breastfeeding Association for 6 years. Through her business, Your Lactation Biz, Tash coaches and creates products to help new and seasoned IBCLCs build businesses that suit their personality and lifestyle.

Leave a Comment