What is the difference between a breast shield and a nipple shield?

Understanding the Difference: Breast Shields vs. Nipple Shields
In the realm of breastfeeding aids, the terms breast shield and nipple shield are often used interchangeably, leading to confusion among new mothers. However, these two devices serve distinct purposes and are designed for different situations.
What is a Nipple Shield?
A nipple shield is a specialized breastfeeding aid that is placed over the nipple and areola during nursing. Its primary function is to assist mothers who may face challenges with breastfeeding, such as flat or inverted nipples, which can make it difficult for infants to latch effectively. The shield mimics the shape of a natural nipple, providing a larger surface area for the baby to latch onto, thereby facilitating feeding .
Nipple shields are typically made from thin, flexible silicone and feature a small opening at the tip that allows milk to flow into the baby’s mouth. They are recommended for temporary use, particularly in situations where the baby struggles to latch or when the mother experiences pain during nursing. Experts advise that while nipple shields can be beneficial, they should be used under guidance and for as short a duration as possible to avoid potential issues with milk supply or breastfeeding technique.
What is a Breast Shield?
In contrast, a breast shield is designed primarily for protection rather than direct assistance with breastfeeding. These devices are typically used to shield the breast from friction and irritation, especially during the early stages of breastfeeding when the nipples may be sore or cracked. Breast shields can help prevent further damage to the nipple tissue and provide a barrier against clothing or other irritants.
Unlike nipple shields, breast shields do not have an opening for milk flow and are not intended to assist with latching. Instead, they serve as a protective measure, allowing mothers to continue breastfeeding comfortably while their nipples heal.
Key Differences
The fundamental difference between the two lies in their functionality and design. Nipple shields are actively used during breastfeeding to aid in latching and feeding, while breast shields are passive devices meant to protect the breast tissue from damage. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for mothers navigating the challenges of breastfeeding, as each device addresses different needs and circumstances.
In summary, while both nipple shields and breast shields are valuable tools for breastfeeding mothers, they cater to different aspects of the breastfeeding experience. Nipple shields facilitate feeding, particularly in challenging situations, whereas breast shields focus on protecting the nipples from irritation and injury.

What is the most likely reason for recommending a nipple shield?

Nipple shields are usually recommended to mothers for flat nipples or in cases in which there is a failure of the baby to effectively latch onto the breast within the first 2 days postpartum.

Is it bad to use a nipple shield long term?

Note: If your baby is growing well the nipple shield can be used for a prolonged period of time. Maintaining a good milk supply: > It may be necessary to express after breastfeeds, especially if your breastmilk supply is low or your baby has a weak suck. If your baby is growing well this will not be necessary.

Why aren’t nipple shields recommended?

Why shouldn’t all moms use a nipple shield? The thin silicone layer of the shield interferes with the normal sensory feedback between the baby and the breast. Many moms find their milk supply gradually decreases with the shield.

Why are nipple shields discouraged?

Although nipple shields may be a useful tool in certain situations, they also may cause challenges. Nipple shields create a barrier, may exacerbate latch issues when mom attempts to go back to direct breastfeeding, and they can lead to poor milk transfer and decrease mom’s milk supply.

What is the difference between nipple and breast shield?

If you decide to purchase one, you can find them on Amazon. A nipple shield is usually an aid for the baby to latch to breast when nursing and is not always needed, it also has nothing to do with pumping. However, a breast shield is another name for a flange and that is what you need to pump with.

How to get baby to latch deeper?

With your baby’s head tilted back and chin up, lift him or her to touch your nipple. The nipple should rest just above the baby’s upper lip. Wait for your baby to open very wide, then “scoop” the breast by placing the lower jaw on first. Now tip your baby’s head forward and place the upper jaw well behind your nipple.

What is the purpose of a nipple shield?

A nipple shield is like a second nipple. It goes over your areola and nipple and has tiny holes at the end where milk can transfer from your nipple to your baby’s mouth. It helps infants with trouble latching onto the breast by acting like a longer, firmer nipple.

How do I know if I need a nipple shield?

If your baby is not nursing at all, or is nursing ineffectively despite improving attachment and increasing milk flow, a nipple shield may help by providing a firmer stimulus in your baby’s mouth. A nipple shield may be a useful tool in some situations.

How to choose the correct nipple shield size?

Be sure to measure only the nipple and exclude the areola, the darker area around the nipple. Once you have measured your nipple, add approximately 0 – 3mm. For instance, 18mm + 3mm = 21mm breast shield size. It’s important to measure both sides since one side may require a different size than the other.

Is it OK to use nipple shield permanently?

A nipple shield is usually only used once your milk supply has increased in amount and changed from colostrum to mature milk. This usually happens 2 to 5 days after the birth. In most cases, you only need to use a nipple shield for a short time.